{"data":[{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-020","pairNumber":1,"routingPairId":"v4-020","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":35,"overreachTotal":64,"pairRationale":"The pair shows weak coherence (C=35) and high overreach (O=64) due to the lack of a documented interface between P1's experimental single-ion control and P2's theoretical topological qudit codes, leading to speculative integration claims.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2506.09371","title":"Efficient Implementation of a Quantum Algorithm with a Trapped Ion Qudit"},{"arxivId":"2511.15783","title":"Automorphism in Gauge Theories: Higher Symmetries and Transversal Non-Clifford Logical Gates"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-020","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-036","pairNumber":2,"routingPairId":"v4-036","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":37,"overreachTotal":67,"pairRationale":"No explicit interface exists between P1\"s\" intra-PQC noise mitigation and P2\"s\" SARA-H materials discovery framework. While both utilize learning-based methodologies, the lack of shared data representation, defined handoff protocol, or joint benchmark results in significant speculative mechanism and validation gaps. The fusion relies on unvalidated assumptions about QPU compatibility within a classical laboratory feedback loop.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2406.00843","title":"Diffusion-Inspired Quantum Noise Mitigation in Parameterized Quantum Circuits"},{"arxivId":"2601.08185","title":"Autonomous Materials Exploration by Integrating Automated Phase Identification and AI-Assisted Human Reasoning"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-036","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-037","pairNumber":3,"routingPairId":"v4-037","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":21,"overreachTotal":100,"pairRationale":"The fusion lacks a concrete interface; P1 provides a formal photonic framework while P2 addresses classical CFD closure. No shared state encoding, data handoff, or joint benchmark is evidenced. Scoring is conservative for interdependency and synergy, while overreach reflects the massive speculative gap between photonic state prep and Navier-Stokes ROMs.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2409.13541","title":"Fusion and flow: formal protocols to reliably build photonic graph states"},{"arxivId":"2606.09857","title":"Uncertainty-aware Multi-fidelity Closure via Conditional Normalizing Flows"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-037","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-039","pairNumber":4,"routingPairId":"v4-039","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":49,"overreachTotal":53,"pairRationale":"P1 proposes fermion dynamics encodings for quantum hardware, while P2 develops classical recurrent surrogates for semiclassical dynamics. While both address dynamics, P1's requirement for a specific fermionic Hamiltonian and P2's Ehrenfest/Holstein focus create a significant interface gap. The fusion is speculative, lacking a shared representation or validated handoff between the quantum circuit and the classical surrogate, resulting in low coherence and high overreach.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2512.11418","title":"Stabilizer-based quantum simulation of fermion dynamics with local qubit encodings"},{"arxivId":"2412.06631","title":"Recurrent convolutional neural networks for modeling non-adiabatic dynamics of quantum-classical systems"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-039","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-040","pairNumber":5,"routingPairId":"v4-040","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":18,"overreachTotal":99,"pairRationale":"Absent: No interface exists between P1's derivative-constrained PINNs and P2's classical KAN-based IMU activity recognition. The manifest's routing signals for quantum-ML and quantum-PDE are not supported by the primary notes, which explicitly flag P2 as lacking quantum evidence. The papers address disparate domains (physics vs. human activity) with incompatible metrics and benchmarks, rendering the proposed fusion entirely speculative and unvalidated.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2604.13723","title":"Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Solving Derivative-Constrained PDEs"},{"arxivId":"2406.11914","title":"Initial Investigation of Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks (KANs) as Feature Extractors for IMU Based Human Activity Recognition"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-040","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-059","pairNumber":6,"routingPairId":"v4-059","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":4,"overreachTotal":100,"pairRationale":"Absent: P1 evidence is missing due to HTML failure, and P2 is a classical particle data compressor. No interface, shared mechanism, or quantum capability is evidenced in the primary notes. The pair represents a speculative fusion of unrelated classical HPC tools with zero demonstrated interdependency, leading to minimal coherence and maximal overreach scores.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2403.05910","title":"XFLUIDS: A SYCL-based unified cross-architecture heterogeneous simulation solver for compressible reacting flows"},{"arxivId":"2411.00761","title":"LCP: Enhancing Scientific Data Management with Lossy Compression for Particles"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-059","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-060","pairNumber":7,"routingPairId":"v4-060","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":20,"overreachTotal":79,"pairRationale":"P1 maps jet clustering to QAOA on superconducting hardware, while P2 optimizes classical LLM pretraining on 9600 GPUs. The proposed fusion lacks a concrete interface, as GPU topology-aware scheduling does not directly translate to quantum circuit connectivity or noise mitigation. Without a shared representation, benchmark, or hardware-level integration mechanism, the pairing remains speculative and domain-mismatched, resulting in low coherence and high overreach.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2407.09056","title":"A Novel Quantum Realization of Jet Clustering in High-Energy Physics Experiments"},{"arxivId":"2509.15940","title":"Efficient Pre-Training of LLMs via Topology-Aware Communication Alignment on More Than 9600 GPUs"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-060","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-076","pairNumber":8,"routingPairId":"v4-076","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":6,"overreachTotal":100,"pairRationale":"The fusion of a classical SYCL-based CFD solver (P1) with a 1+1D QFT tensor-network framework (P2) is entirely incoherent. P2 explicitly disclaims a validated bridge to external HPC/PDE pipelines, and P1's evidence is currently missing, resulting in extreme overreach.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2403.05910","title":"XFLUIDS: A SYCL-based unified cross-architecture heterogeneous simulation solver for compressible reacting flows"},{"arxivId":"2404.11715","title":"Entanglement Renormalization for Quantum Field Theories with Discrete Wavelet Transforms"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-076","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-077","pairNumber":9,"routingPairId":"v4-077","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":53,"overreachTotal":53,"pairRationale":"The pair lacks a stated interface between P1's measurement-based qudit cooling and P2's permutation-invariant codes. While both share a qudit foundation, P1's topology-dependent failure and P2's deletion-error focus remain separate. The proposed fusion is speculative, lacking joint benchmarks or a compatible noise model, resulting in low algorithmic synergy and a significant empirical validation gap.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved; no withdrawn caveats apply","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2409.08375","title":"Measurement-based qudit quantum refrigerator with subspace cooling"},{"arxivId":"2603.10981","title":"Permutation-invariant codes: a numerical study and qudit constructions"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-077","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-078","pairNumber":10,"routingPairId":"v4-078","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":8,"overreachTotal":100,"pairRationale":"Absent: P1 evidence (2412.07504) is unavailable in the primary source notes, preventing any evidenced interface with P2's Lindblad dynamics (2503.07402). The proposed fusion between genetic code storage and nuclear bound-state formation remains entirely speculative and lacks shared theoretical, methodological, or empirical grounding. Coherence is limited to temporal and venue alignment, while overreach is maximal due to total evidence absence.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved; P1 evidence unavailable in primary source notes","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2412.07504","title":"Deterministic Storage of Quantum Information in the Genetic Code"},{"arxivId":"2503.07402","title":"Bound state formation within the Lindblad approach"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-078","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-079","pairNumber":11,"routingPairId":"v4-079","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":53,"overreachTotal":61,"pairRationale":"The fusion lacks a concrete interface; P2's graph-theoretic formalism for qudit graph states is not mapped to P1's specific 137Ba+ single-ion control hardware. While both share a qudit foundation, the absence of multi-qudit entanglement in P1 and ideal qudit assumptions in P2 create significant implementation gaps and speculative scaling risks, resulting in weak algorithmic synergy and high overreach.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2506.09371","title":"Efficient Implementation of a Quantum Algorithm with a Trapped Ion Qudit"},{"arxivId":"2402.10678","title":"Covering a Graph with Minimal Local Sets"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-079","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-080","pairNumber":12,"routingPairId":"v4-080","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":33,"overreachTotal":88,"pairRationale":"The pair exhibits poor coherence and severe overreach because there is no documented interface between the experimental multi-core fiber QKD and the theoretical graph-state algorithm, relying instead on speculative mechanisms and unjustified extrapolation across distinct domains.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2606.04211","title":"High-Dimensional Quantum Key Distribution via full Core-mode Encoding over Deployed Multicore Fibers"},{"arxivId":"2402.10678","title":"Covering a Graph with Minimal Local Sets"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-080","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-116","pairNumber":13,"routingPairId":"v4-116","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":13,"overreachTotal":97,"pairRationale":"The pair is fundamentally incoherent as it attempts to fuse a low-level quantum-classical Hessian inversion scheduler for neural network training (P1) with a domain-specific classical household energy storage sizing and scheduling model (P2). No documented interface, shared representation, or joint validation protocol exists between these disparate domains.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2405.00252","title":"Q-Newton: Hybrid Quantum-Classical Scheduling for Accelerating Neural Network Training with Newton's Gradient Descent"},{"arxivId":"2506.17268","title":"Optimal Operating Strategy for PV-BESS Households: Balancing Self-Consumption and Self-Sufficiency"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-116","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-118","pairNumber":14,"routingPairId":"v4-118","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":18,"overreachTotal":100,"pairRationale":"The pair combines two distinct classical domains: PINN meta-learning for PDEs (P1) and RRAM-CIM hardware inference (P2). Lacking a documented cross-paper interface, shared benchmarks, or compatible hardware-software models, the fusion is purely speculative and non-coherent.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2412.00225","title":"Meta-learning Loss Functions of Parametric Partial Differential Equations Using Physics-Informed Neural Networks"},{"arxivId":"2505.14303","title":"Optimizing Binary and Ternary Neural Network Inference on RRAM Crossbars using CIM-Explorer"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-118","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-119","pairNumber":15,"routingPairId":"v4-119","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":30,"overreachTotal":74,"pairRationale":"No explicit interface is stated between P1's PINN meta-learning and P2's RL infrastructure. Both are classical papers lacking quantum mechanisms, circuit definitions, or shared benchmarks. The fusion is speculative, relying on generic 'learning' terminology without evidence of algorithmic synergy or a data-handoff protocol. Consequently, coherence is low due to missing quantum foundations, and overreach is high due to unvalidated scaling and integration claims.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2412.00225","title":"Meta-learning Loss Functions of Parametric Partial Differential Equations Using Physics-Informed Neural Networks"},{"arxivId":"2509.15965","title":"RLinf: Flexible and Efficient Large-scale Reinforcement Learning via Macro-to-Micro Flow Transformation"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-119","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-136","pairNumber":16,"routingPairId":"v4-136","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":32,"overreachTotal":73,"pairRationale":"The pair lacks a documented interface between the Q-Newton scheduler and graphene PINN, resulting in low coherence across methodological dimensions, while speculative quantum hardware and unvalidated scaling drive high overreach scores, necessitating a tier2 classification.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2405.00252","title":"Q-Newton: Hybrid Quantum-Classical Scheduling for Accelerating Neural Network Training with Newton's Gradient Descent"},{"arxivId":"2508.10718","title":"Symmetry-Constrained Multi-Scale Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Graphene Electronic Band Structure Prediction"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-136","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-137","pairNumber":17,"routingPairId":"v4-137","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":55,"overreachTotal":44,"pairRationale":"Both papers provide strong evidence for VQE-based quantum chemistry workflows within the same era and methodological framework. However, the lack of a documented interface between transfer learning and specific impurity models results in speculative synergy and unexamined interaction effects.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2406.08554","title":"Quantum Hardware-Enabled Molecular Dynamics via Transfer Learning"},{"arxivId":"2410.12733","title":"Quantum Embedding of Non-local Quantum Many-body Interactions in Prototypal Anti-tumor Vaccine Metalloprotein on Near Term Quantum Computing Hardware"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-137","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":"Downgrade: source notes expressly require an interface that is absent; primary-paper merit cannot substitute for pair-level evidence.","evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-139","pairNumber":18,"routingPairId":"v4-139","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":47,"overreachTotal":82,"pairRationale":"The pair lacks a documented cross-paper interface for execution or data exchange, as noted in primary source records. While both papers share a theoretical foundation in classical GPU scheduling, the proposed fusion into a quantum context is speculative and unvalidated, resulting in low coherence and high overreach scores.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2501.05563","title":"Prediction-Assisted Online Distributed Deep Learning Workload Scheduling in GPU Clusters"},{"arxivId":"2509.15940","title":"Efficient Pre-Training of LLMs via Topology-Aware Communication Alignment on More Than 9600 GPUs"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-139","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-140","pairNumber":19,"routingPairId":"v4-140","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":47,"overreachTotal":57,"pairRationale":"The pair lacks an explicit interface between P1's weighted VMC for the Heisenberg chain and P2's Gauss-Newton PINNs for Navier-Stokes. While both utilize gradient-based optimization, the lack of shared representation, mapping, or joint benchmarks makes the fusion highly speculative, resulting in low coherence and high overreach due to significant validation gaps and scope creep.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved; include withdrawn caveat if relevant","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2507.01905","title":"Improved energies and wave function accuracy with Weighted Variational Monte Carlo"},{"arxivId":"2402.10680","title":"Gauss-Newton Natural Gradient Descent for Physics-Informed Computational Fluid Dynamics"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-140","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."},{"certificationId":"v4-cert-v4-156","pairNumber":20,"routingPairId":"v4-156","classification":"tier2","coherenceTotal":16,"overreachTotal":91,"pairRationale":"P1 is a hybrid quantum–classical scheduler, whereas P2 measures and models emergent interfacial magnetism. The PDF establishes no quantum algorithm, QUBO, scheduling target, or data/control handoff in P2; this pair is incompatible without a new, untested research program.","sourceStatus":"both primary records retrieved; 2502.13018 uses controlled cached PDF fallback where applicable","evidenceStatus":"primary_full_paper","certificationMethod":"fixed_xpqa_25_coherence_25_overreach_v1","cohortLockSha256":"1553ae031be56cfd32966379d149e2622cc172e11a00fca3c92c3d92c90810ca","primarySources":[{"arxivId":"2405.00252","title":"Q-Newton: Hybrid Quantum-Classical Scheduling for Accelerating Neural Network Training with Newton's Gradient Descent"},{"arxivId":"2502.13018","title":"Artificially creating emergent interfacial antiferromagnetism and its manipulation in a magnetic van-der-Waals heterostructure"}],"scorecardUrl":"/api/v1/v4-full-paper-certifications/v4-156","pvlInterfaceFirstStatus":null,"evidenceBoundary":"This is a verified full-paper scorecard for a fixed V4 review cohort. Tier-2 means the paired synthesis does not meet the fixed current certification threshold; it does not assess either paper’s standalone merit."}],"meta":{"total":43,"limit":20,"offset":0,"nextOffset":20,"classificationTotals":{"full_pass":0,"tier1_marginal":0,"tier2":43},"scoringContract":{"full_pass":"coherence >= 70 and overreach <= 30","tier1_marginal":"coherence >= 60 and overreach <= 40"},"readOnly":true,"evidenceBoundary":"Primary arXiv HTML evidence retained in v4_primary_source_notes.md; archived v1 HTML used for withdrawn 2601.18060."}}